Not to argue SingleShotShorty, but trying to rationalize what a DOG thinks, in terms of the WAY A HUMAN THINKS, is a FAR DUMBER IDEA, and I have heard you analogy MANY TIMES.
HOW WOULD "YOU FEEL" IF WHEN YOUR BUDDY SHOT A DUCK, HE TOLD "YOU" TO JUMP IN THE COLD WATER AND SWIM OUT AND GET IT JUST IN YOUR BIRTHDAY SUIT?
You wouldn't do it but, the dog LOVES IT AND TO HIM "IT'S A GREAT IDEA".
You and the dog do not think alike. "I HOPE".
As far as being BORN GUNSHY? Well let's say that out of a litter of say NINE WELL BRED PUPS, only ONE makes a good patrol dog, and then a year later out of the same stud, and bitch, ANOTHER LITTER OF NINE PUPS, is born and FIVE of them make good patrol dogs. HMMMMMM.
Dogs DO NOT RATIONALIZE things as humans do. To even ASSUME they might is a mistake, BUT, some have a stronger CHARCTER than others, are BOLDER, or SHYER, are HIGHER on prey drive, or LOWER, are HIGHER on SOCIAL DRIVE, or LOWER. Breeding though important is NOT the end all, in getting GOOD PUPS EVERY TIME. People prove this daily.