One of the Magazines, either Outdoor Life or F&S did a review of the icon and the next month....or maybe the same month but the other magazine.....did a review of the S&W I-bolt.
I read both articles a few times. The writers absolutely loved the Thompson Center Icon. They had a few nit-pickey things to say, but that's to be expected.....however, they loved the Icon.
Now, the I-bolt was a different story. First they "qualified" the review by saying they tested a "prototype" model. But then somewhere in the story they said it was "almost" the finished product. BTW, FWIW Thompson Center produces the barrel for the I-bolt and was contracted to do this before the acquisition. (or so S&W has said). But essentially, if you "read between the lines" of the I-bolt review, the writers were being polite to one of their big advertisers, while at the same time bashing the crap out of the first time rifle. Essentially what I read was for the money, buy anything else...and you will buy a better gun.
The T\C article basically stated if you buy the Icon, you have bot a good quality gun. Now.....caliber....if you get it in the new 30 T\C...that's another matter. But rechambereing can always be done. So that's not a big deal.
MHO
Dave