Neald,
Nothing wrong with one of each. I guess the advantage of the G2 is that I could get the in-line M\L barrel for it, and the other advantage would be if the hammer is cocked, and then de-cocked, the frame doesn't have to be opened to re-set the trigger like it does on the older frames.
However, if I want an in-line M\L I can just get one for the Encore (which I already had a trigger job done on as the factory pull had major creep and was heavy). The trigger on the older Contenders are good as they come from the factory or if they need work, they are not difficult to do.
So, now that I think about it, I don't see a compelling reason to buy a new G2 frame over the older type.
Thanks. It always helps to have a ear to bounce this stuff off of.
Dave