I have one, and it has a barrel alignment broblem... I've heard of it happening before with the same gun. Other than that its a good pistol, smooth action, shoots well. When going to buy it, get a small flashlight, and make sure that the cylinder lines up with the barrel, if not, don't buy it. If you find a good one, I would recommend it. I have a friend who has a S&W scandium in the .357 mag, and that is just a sweet pistol, everything is top of the line on it. If you don't mind spending the money, I would go with the smith. You won't be let down one the taurus, as long as you check to make sure it's aligned correctly, and the cylinder slides out and in smoothly (another problem I've heard of) These problems seem to be one gun specific, and not with every one.