The 6.5-284 can be built on a short action and makes an ideal, light, flat shooting deer rifle. Be sure the smith that builds your rifle has experience with .284 cases rifles. some rifle require mods to the magazine and/or follower to make them feed well. I have a Model Seven I built for my son when he was born. He killed his first deer with it this year at age 11.
If you use a short action the somewhat, longish for thier weight, 6.5 bullets will take up some space in the case and reduce your powder capacity. This is not much of a problem unless you plan on pushing the envelope on velocity. I can get over 2980 FPS out of a 120 grain Sierra Game King and close to that out of a 129 grain Hornady SP Interlock using H4831 and a CCI Benchrest primer. That nips at the heels of a long action .270 and my Model Seven only has a 20" barrel. Most .270's have at least a 22 or 24".
My gunsmith's son has a 6.5-284 that is built on 30-06 standard action with a 22" barrel. He can beat my 120 and 129 grain bullet velocities by 150 FPS with most loadings because he can seat his bullet out a lot farther than me, for more powder room, and still fit the magazine. The same gunsmith has a 6.5-06 with a 22" barrel. Velocities are almost identical to the 6.5-284 on the long action but the 6.5-284 is a touch more accurate. I am not sure why but it may be due to the short, fat case.
If I had my choice and was building a standard action hunting rifle and was handloading anyway I would probably go for the 6.5-06. Brass is easy to get from .270's, 30-06's and 25-06's. Velocities are almost identical to a 6.5-284 built on a long action and the accuracy issue would be moot on a target the size of a deer's shoulder.
I built my son's rifle in 6.5-284 due to the fact I had a Model Seven Youth Model to begin with and I wanted to be sure he learned to reload by giving him a cartridge he had to form brass for and reload due to a lack of factory ammo. Now it looks as though we have factory brass and maybe soon factory ammo. Hummm, well I guess I wont tell him until he learns to do his own.
