Author Topic: new slug gun  (Read 2854 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline wild willy

  • GBO Supporter
  • Trade Count: (2)
  • Avid Poster
  • *****
  • Posts: 228
new slug gun
« on: August 20, 2004, 09:22:36 AM »
Getting a new ultra...Which gauge should I get? It will be used for whitetails.  Anyone have a Nikon 2-7 Prostaff scope?  What rings for this scope?

Offline WNY_Whitetailer

  • Look at me I'm white and nerdy
  • Moderator
  • Trade Count: (2)
  • Senior Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1828
  • Gender: Male
  • Working...
    • http://www.dec.state.ny.us/
new slug gun
« Reply #1 on: August 20, 2004, 10:53:04 AM »
A 20ga Ultra Slugger is more than enough to get the job done out to 100-125 yards...If you prefer a 12ga then that is the route I would go.  I have Millett High Rings on my Ultra Slugger.  Those rings hold a Bushnell Trophy 1.75-4x32 Scope.  Make sure that your Nikon has sufficient eye relief so that you don't get "scope" eye...Good luck.
Patience comes with age and You can't teach common sense

Offline Busta

  • GBO Supporter
  • Trade Count: (5)
  • Senior Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2586
  • Gender: Male
new slug gun
« Reply #2 on: August 20, 2004, 05:56:32 PM »
A vote for the 20ga, shooting 260gr Remington Ultra Core-Lokt or 260gr Winchester Partition Golds. The recoil is very mild in the 20ga, the 12ga loads are heavier and recoil is greater. Good luck!
U.S.A.F. Veteran
NRA Life Member

Offline MTNMAN

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Avid Poster
  • **
  • Posts: 143
new slug gun
« Reply #3 on: August 21, 2004, 03:49:53 AM »
Gotta agree with Busta...I've owned a 20 Ultra since they forst came out... The deer don't know the difference between a 20 and a 12 but the shoulder sure does....Mine seems to like the 3" Federal magnum sabots... MTNMAN :grin:
Patience comes with age & you can't teach common sense

Jeff Gannon who was known to his many friends here as Mtnman passed away the other day. 09-27-05

Offline DaveH

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 438
new slug gun
« Reply #4 on: August 21, 2004, 05:31:24 AM »
Has anyone tried the new buck hammers from remington in their 20 ga slug guns ?  I used them in my tracker II 12 ga last year and they shot very good.  Just wondering if they will be as good in my tracker II 20 ga.

Dave H.
Dave H.
US Army SFC(Ret)

Offline Markus

  • Moderators
  • Moderator
  • Trade Count: (15)
  • Senior Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1767
  • Gender: Male
new slug gun
« Reply #5 on: August 21, 2004, 09:17:33 AM »
I've got no experience with the 20ga ultra myself but based on all the recomendations I've seen on this board and the old H&R Talk over the years I plan on picking one up this fall. My 1st dozen or so deer fell to 20ga rifled slugs in my old topper and the modern slugs are far superior as far as on game performance. I'd get the 20.
PROUD REDNECK CONSERVATIVE

I'd much rather be remembered for being a great shot than having the most expensive gun

Offline JohnDY

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Member
  • *
  • Posts: 63
new slug gun
« Reply #6 on: August 21, 2004, 09:49:04 AM »
I've got a 12g Ultra with a 1-4x 32mm  Bushnell Banner scope in medium rings. While I really like the gun if I had it to do over again I would get the 20g. My reasons being the recoil with a 20g is a little less, the gun is going to be a little lighter and with 20g you get a 12g frame and not the 10g frame. The only other barrels I can get for my 12g Ultra are 10g shotgun barrels. If you get a 20g Ultra you could send the gun back to H&R for a Huntsman black powder barrel or any 12g barrel.
JohnDY

Offline jeff223

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Senior Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1284
new slug gun
« Reply #7 on: August 21, 2004, 11:01:00 AM »

the 20 works good as you can see but there is nothing wrong with a 12ga

Offline HuntenNut

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 270
new slug gun
« Reply #8 on: August 22, 2004, 05:59:32 AM »
20ga has less recoil but its the only advantage. The 12ga Ultra is a very heavy gun, and absorbs the recoil pretty well. If you can handle it, go with the 12ga.

The 12ga has more recoil and undoubtedly lots more power and range (I know the 20ga has "enough", but can never go wrong with more).

The other advantage to the 12ga is that there is much more variety of available factory ammunition as well as reloading components.

Offline Markus

  • Moderators
  • Moderator
  • Trade Count: (15)
  • Senior Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1767
  • Gender: Male
new slug gun
« Reply #9 on: August 25, 2004, 04:05:23 PM »
I used to have the same thoughts as Huntennut but as far as the only advantage being less recoil I'd add to that reduced carry wieght which is an issue if you do some walkin with it. Another advantage is that you can add any shotgun barrel (except for 10 ga)or a huntsman barrel. Asfor range FRom all I've heard and read I don't think there is an appreciable difference. Power the 12 definitely wins but the 20 is more than just adequate. As far as ammo goes 12 is a little more plentiful but my local walmart always has 20 and the gunstore are never out of stock that I've noticed. I don't have a 20 ultra yet but these are the considerations that are leading me to buy one.
PROUD REDNECK CONSERVATIVE

I'd much rather be remembered for being a great shot than having the most expensive gun

Offline HuntenNut

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 270
new slug gun
« Reply #10 on: August 26, 2004, 03:43:07 AM »
Well, if its a light gun you are after, neither of these will do. The 20ga Ultra is still pretty heavy by my standards. You'd be better served with a Tracker II or even a pump gun if you want lighter.


As far as availablity goes, was just at Gander Mountain yesterday. They had piles of 12ga slugs from every manufacturer, however only a few boxes of 20's, and not even from every manufacturer. They will likely get more just before season, but year round availablitity is much better for the 12ga. I don't think you can say that 20's are just as available as 12's. This may not be a factor if you plan ahead, but lets face it, we've all been caught last minute at least once. At least with the 12ga, you will know you'll be able to find your preferred load without driving all over town searching.

Also, it is a fact that many of the slug reloading components available are only made for the 12. Check out the Sabot Technologies website.

Finally to ballistics. Most of the premium ammo will give you well over 1000lb-ft more energy with the 12 than the 20 and thats not just at the muzzle. The superior energy is maintained out to any effective range and beyond. Now the 20 is "adequate" but I'd say the 12 is quite a bit more than "marginally" superior on the ballistics. Also, it punches a bigger hole so its not just numbers better, it also has more shock power. And because the 12ga is so much heavier, it will be less effected by cross winds which may not show up on the published trajectory, but will definitely have an effect on longer range shots in the real world.

As to barrels, Im not big on the barrel program myself due to the shipping cost/barrel fit fee and turnaround time, preferring to buy the whole gun anyway, but if I did want a barrel, I could get the 10ga for my 12ga ultra, so its a wash because that barrel won't fit a 20ga ultra. Depends on what barrel you're after.

Offline scruffy

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • A Real Regular
  • ****
  • Posts: 526
new slug gun
« Reply #11 on: August 26, 2004, 04:55:07 AM »
I was a 12 gauge slugger for years (Iowa's a slug only state for deer) but have changed from the 12 to the 20 for sabotted slugs.  The new 20 gauge sabbots are more than just "adequate" for deer.  Compare the 20 gauge sabotted 45 caliber bullets pushed at 1900fps 260 grain winchester partitions golds, Remington Core-Lokt ultra bonded, and new Federal Barnes Expander ballistics and compare them to a factory 300 grain 45-70.  I don't think many would consider a 300grain 45-70 round as just "adequate" for deer.  The high velocity 20 gauge/45 caliber sabots have 1500+ft/lbs of energy at 100 yards, more than the 300 grain remington 45-70 offering.  Both the 45-70 and 20 gauge/45 caliber sabots should drop below 1000ft/lbs a little past 200 yards.

So yes, a 12 gauge has more energy, does more damage, and all of that.  But keep in mind todays 20 gauge sabots aren't your dad's 20 gauge slugs.  They are more than adequate, and some could argue overkill for whitetail.  The new 12 gauge slugs are just too execessive for my shoulder to tolerate any longer.  I still have my 12 gauge slug guns but I use the 20 most of the time.  It's as much or more slug than you'll ever need.

And the biggest advantage to the 20 gauge ultra for a stand gun, when it's loaded up with the steel bar in the stock the big bull barreled slugger doesn't kick hardly at all.  I watch the slug impact the paper target when shooting the slower 1450 fps Fed Barnes Expanders (haven't tried the 1900fps stuff to see if I can still see the impacts).  Makes for very accurate shooting when your not flenching, or fear getting "kicked" out of the tree.  I'd never take a 12 gauge tracker up in a tree.  I take a step back on the ground shooting foster slugs through my light weight pardner 12 gauge, I can't imagine being in a tree with an even lighter tracker II.  :eek:

Just my humble two cents worth.  :wink:

later,
scruffy
Hunting is 99% brain, 1% gun

Offline MTNMAN

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Avid Poster
  • **
  • Posts: 143
new slug gun
« Reply #12 on: August 26, 2004, 05:33:17 AM »
To those concerned with the weight of the Ultra and want a lighter Pump Gun consider this....

MODEL 870™ SPS™ "SUPER SLUG" GUN weighs 8lbs empty, and minus the scope, that ain't a whole lot of difference when ya fill it to capacity and mount the scope... and it's a sight better than heftin' an 1187 @ 11lbs. minus the scope and ammo... :wink:
Patience comes with age & you can't teach common sense

Jeff Gannon who was known to his many friends here as Mtnman passed away the other day. 09-27-05

Offline HuntenNut

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 270
new slug gun
« Reply #13 on: August 26, 2004, 06:45:44 AM »
Mtn Man,

My 12ga ultra weighs about 10lbs w/o scope, I'd bet the 20ga ultra isn't much lighter although I don't have one to weigh. I actually prefer the heavier gun for stand hunting. but neither gun is going to be good for carrying around all day. My point was not that the Ultras are too heavy, just that I don't think the 20ga could be that much lighter and that they are both probably very heavy compared to other guns that are available if weight is your concern.

The point about adding weight for the scope is moot, cause the same weight would need to be added to the Ultra. Also, I see no point in carrying a full magazine, maybe one 2nd shot if I was carrying a repeater. Hence, it only makes sense to look at the empty weight of the gun sans scope and mount.

You are correct about the 870, however, consider:

Mossy 500 7-1/4lbs
Ithaca Deerslayer 7-1/2lbs
Verona sx405 6-1/2lbs Yes, thats right, I just held one yesterday. Considering this one seriously as my next walking gun. Only a pound heavier than the Tracker and it can be scoped. A bit longer OAL though
remington 1100 7-1/2lbs
Many other repeaters also 7-1/2lbs or less, considerably lighter than the Ultraslugs.

Tracker 2 barely 5lbs and very short OAL :grin:  Now thats a walkin gun. Too bad you can't scope it. :cry:

Offline MTNMAN

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Avid Poster
  • **
  • Posts: 143
new slug gun
« Reply #14 on: August 26, 2004, 07:57:16 AM »
The Tracker II in 20 gauge has more than enough meat to be scoped....remove the steel bar (1.9Lbs) from the Butt Stock and yup I agree a very nice walk around gun indeed...not much recoil either minus that bar....Been doin' deer with a 20, in some way shape or form, for the past 50 years and the biggest portion of those years with a single shot smooth bore...

My Ultra20 weighed 9Lbs. even until I removed that steel bar...always liked my guns a little front heavy turned out just right when I added the scope....

HuntenNut, I wasn't pickin' on ya...just tired of readin' in every post of how heavy the Ultra's are when in reality they ain't that much heavier than what the average Joe carries into the woods...there's always ways around the weight issue... MTNMAN
Patience comes with age & you can't teach common sense

Jeff Gannon who was known to his many friends here as Mtnman passed away the other day. 09-27-05

Offline scruffy

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • A Real Regular
  • ****
  • Posts: 526
new slug gun
« Reply #15 on: August 26, 2004, 09:15:32 AM »
Yep, I ditto what MNTMAN said, with the scope and steel bar my ultra 20 weighs right at 10lbs, and with the steel bar removed from the stock my ultra 20 with scope weighs in the 8.5lb range.  I usually keep the bar in the stock as it's my stand gun and steady hold (resting on wrap around bar on front of ladder stand) and almost no recoil are very important to me.

To use it as a carry gun, which I did opening day last year, removing the steel bar does wonders.  It's nose heavy, but still steady to hold off hand.  At 8.5lbs it is only .5lb heavier than my scoped .270 weatherby rifle.  So while it's not the lightest "carry" gun out there, it's arguably the most accurate.

You can also put a synthetic butt stock on it like Jeff223's ultra 20 and drop another .5lb.  Get a "survivor" forend and some sand paper to open it up a little and replace the wood forearm, drop a few more ounces.  And you could get really ambitious and cut the barrel from 24" to 20" (I think that will give a AOL of 36", the legal short limit for a shotgun if memory serves, or it it 30" for shortest legal AOL? anyway....) and drop a some more ounces.

But 8.5lbs scoped just isn't that overly heavy I don't think.  You're talking a little over a half pound more than a Remington 700 BDL long action deer rifle.

And if you're going to be walking alot during the season please get out and walk long distances before the season opens.  Too many of my friends don't walk much father than the distance between the house and the mail box before season opens, it's no wonder they get dead tired.  Also, too many hunters that I see think hunting is a contest to see how much ground you can cover in a day.  My uncles are like this.  When hunting with them we'd cover half a county in a day on foot it seemed like.  We'd see deer, but they were alway moving away from us, well aware we were coming through.  Hunting is not about walking a marathon's distance, slow down, stop, kneel down or sit down for a bit.  And don't sit relaxed either, be ready!  You'd be surprised how many times you bump a deer and not know it only to have him circle and come back in to your area after 15 to 30 minutes to lay back down.  Have the gun sitting on your knee and ready to shoulder for when he/she comes walking back to their warm bed.  Also, you'd be surprised how many big bucks just lay there watching you walk by.  After sitting there for a time some deer can't take it and get up and run.  Or like one of my relatives, found himself looking at a huge typical 18 point buck 15 yards away from him laying down under some thick brush.  My cousin shouldered his shotgun and the buck now hangs on the wall.  Had he not stopped to rest a bit he would have walked right by the trophy.

Edit: also, you'll feel a much bigger difference at the end of the day by having a pair of light weight boots (not saying not warm, I mean made from light weight materials) than you ever will carrying a 7lb shotgun verses an 8.5lb shotgun.  IMHO you should spend the $$$ on good boots, or save up to do so.  Kind of like the quote "the rifle's accuracy is only as good as the scope", you could say "the hunters endurance is only as good as his boots."

Now that being said, with the ultra 12, it's a cannon.  Even with the bar removed I doubt it would weigh under 10lbs scoped.  The ultra 20 however is smaller and can be lightened to a very managible carry weight.  Still heavier than other "carry" shotguns on the market, but from experience the ultra is more accurate (I've shot Win, Rem, and Moss slug guns).

Oh, the Remington 1100 cantilever deer gun weighs 7.5bls but doesn't accept anything over 2 3/4" shells, according to Remington's web site.  The 11-87 cantilever deer gun does accept 3" mag loads, but weighs in at 8.5lbs without scope.  With the scope the 11-87 would be heavier than the "rodless" ultra 20.

And on a side note, I'm sure they're out there, but I've never hunted with anyone that didn't fill the magazine of there shotgun.  I've hunted with probably well over 100 different people over the years, all had the magazine full, and if they could have put in more rounds they would have...  :roll:   They all look at me like this when they see I'm using a single shot -  :shock:  Except for one guy I don't hunt with any more but still see every year, who also uses an ultra 20.  It's his carry shotgun on deer drives and he has shot more deer than anyone else in his 20 person hunting party (20 people = why I don't hunt with them anymore...).

Hey, Wild willy, is your ultra going to be a stand shotgun or a carry gun?

later,
scruffy
Hunting is 99% brain, 1% gun

Offline HuntenNut

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 270
new slug gun
« Reply #16 on: August 26, 2004, 11:50:13 AM »
Still can't see any advantage to the 20 other than recoil. If you can manage the 12, why not have the extra power and wider available ammo? These are not bench rest rifles that are shot 1000's of rounds, so I'll take the extra recoil. And I can't remember ever feeling the recoil when shooting at game.

I think the 2 main advantages of the 12 are Power and Availability of ammunition vs only 1 main advantage to the 20, less recoil. Power and avialable ammo are way more important to me than recoil, which doesn't bother me. If recoil is more important to you than both power and availability of ammo, then by all means, take the 20ga.

By the reports above, weight is NOT an advantage of the 20ga vs 12ga Ultra, as there isn't a significant difference in the 2, and there are way lighter 12ga's available if you want a light BALANCED gun. If your 20 weighs 10lbs with scope, then its right up there with the 12 as I suspected in weight. My 12 weighs 10lbs w/o scope but with the rail attached. Typical scope set up for shotgun being under a pound, that means the 20 is less than a pound lighter than the 12. Even if its "featherweighted" by removing the bar, etc, the gun is still way heavier than other 12ga options (by the way about the Rem 1100 being restricted to 2-3/4" shells, I only know of a couple of 3" sabots and their performance is only marginally better than their 2-3/4" cousins<100fps muzzle velocity). Also, I can't see that taking out the bar would not  throw the gun way out of  balance for my taste, especially for a walking gun which needs to be well balanced for quick shots.

Offline gwhilikerz

  • Trade Count: (3)
  • A Real Regular
  • ****
  • Posts: 715
new slug gun
« Reply #17 on: August 26, 2004, 04:25:05 PM »
Well wild willy as you can see by the replies everyone has an opinion :grin: . Whatever gun a person has is what they say is their favorite and they have plenty of facts and other arguments to back up their choices. This is not really a problem until they get into a "my choice is better than your choice" discussion.
The guy with the 12ga says it has much more power. The guy with the 20ga says his is lighter and has adequate power. They are both right. So pick the gun you like the best according to your reasons and be happy.
Now I'm not about to tell these guys that my pardner 20 youth model is the best slug gun. But I am also not in any hurry to "upgrade". I bought what I wanted and I like it. ( and yes it will do the job on any deer that ever walked :grin:

Offline scruffy

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • A Real Regular
  • ****
  • Posts: 526
new slug gun
« Reply #18 on: August 27, 2004, 03:55:06 AM »
Quote from: gwhilikerz
Now I'm not about to tell these guys that my pardner 20 youth model is the best slug gun. But I am also not in any hurry to "upgrade". I bought what I wanted and I like it. ( and yes it will do the job on any deer that ever walked :grin:


GW, I had to laugh when I read your ending.  I've got all these rifled slug guns, years of experience, etc, same as a friend of mine who's been deer hunting all his life also and uses a scoped mossberg bolt slug gun.  And for the last three years we've been absolutely smoked by his now 13 year old son (so since he was 10 years old he's been smoking us...).  He's filled all of his tags and sometimes his dad's deer tags and I think one of my doe tags also ("party" hunting is legal in Iowa during shotgun season).  All of the kid's deer have dropped in 75 yards or less, no misses.  The shots ranged from 15 to 70 yards, and most were on the run.  All were perfect shots.  What does the kid shoot?  A used and abused beat up rusty 870 youth 20 gauge smooth bore short vent rib barrel with modified choke shooting benneke slugs and a small 30mm bsa reddot.  I picked up the youth pump for him at a show four years ago for  next to nothing.  And that little short lightweight youth pump is like an extension to that kids arm.  

Both my friend and I know when he gets bigger he'll want to "upgrade" like you said, and we're both telling him to not forget his youth 870 because he won't ever find another shotgun that fits him better.  Watching him effortlessly shoot a deer is like watching someone raise their hand and pointing their finger at the deer, saying bang, and the deer drops dead, even when the deer is on a "dead" run from being pushed by drivers.

If you have something that works there's no need to "upgrade".  Often times it turns out to be a "downgrade" in the end anyway.  :-)  

later,
scruffy
Hunting is 99% brain, 1% gun

Offline 22KHornet

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Avid Poster
  • **
  • Posts: 194
new slug gun
« Reply #19 on: August 27, 2004, 05:11:34 AM »
I guess I would rather not beat myself up.  Like scruffy said a 20 gauge has more than enough power.  A 260 grn platinum tip at 1700 fps is comparable to the 454 casull which has been credited with bringing down elephants.  Now as big as I would like to think Iowa deer are they are a tad smaller than an elephant :) .  After watching dad get his hat knocked off while shooting his encore last year and remebering my bruised shoulder last year after sighting in I decided to sell the 870 slug barrel and get the ultra 20 gauge.  Oh yes and it fits my rifle receiver as well, shoot a deer in the morning with the ultra slap on the 223 barrel and go look for yotes in the afternoon :grin: yeah right in a perfect world.
I must be crazy.

Offline WNY_Whitetailer

  • Look at me I'm white and nerdy
  • Moderator
  • Trade Count: (2)
  • Senior Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1828
  • Gender: Male
  • Working...
    • http://www.dec.state.ny.us/
new slug gun
« Reply #20 on: August 27, 2004, 08:25:50 AM »
You are better off shooting a gun that you are comfortable than shooting a more powerful gun that you are not comfortable with.  You will shoot the comfortable better than one that is not.

The 12 vs. 20 thing will rage on for a long time...Like Ford Vs Chevy...You can guess who the 20 is.
Patience comes with age and You can't teach common sense

Offline HuntenNut

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 270
new slug gun
« Reply #21 on: August 27, 2004, 01:01:10 PM »
Ok, so the 454 Casull is a good choice, but recoil from 12ga is too much? :roll: The venerable 22lr has brought down big game as well, but I don't think anyone is recommending it. Heck, for that matter, my 9410 is "adequate" on paper for short range shots, but I'd never take that on a deer hunt

Honestly guys, its being made to seem that you've got to be an olympic weightlifter, or even better, an NHL goalie to handle the recoil of the 12ga.

Its really not that bad, especially in a heavy gun like the ultra. Now I wouldn't put 100 rounds through in a day, but I can't afford that anyway with either the 12 or the 20. I have had days where I've put through 8 boxes, thats 40 rounds, without developing a flinch or damaging any major shoulder parts. Now if your talkin the Tracker II, might be a different story.

But if your looking at a heavy gun like the Ultra which soaks up the recoil, I just can't see any point to going to the 20 if its just a recoil issue. The recoil just aint that bad.

The extra power has been argued as unneeded, but what about availability of ammunition and reloading components? Noone has really addressed that.

I was just at Gander Mountain, and while that had stacks of 12ga in every variety, they had only a few 20ga of each. They may stock more during the pre-season, but what if you need something last minute and they're out. Might spend one of your huntin days drivin around town lookin for ammo.

Also, if you want to reload, there are only limited components currently available for 20ga. One of the better slugs available is from Sabot Technologies and they don't even offer it in anything but 12ga. And many of the options availlable from Ballistic Products are only available for 12ga. Trust me, if you want to get serious about shooting slugs, you'll need a lot of money for ammo at $8-$12 per box of 5, or you'll probably consider getting into re-loading them

Offline scruffy

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • A Real Regular
  • ****
  • Posts: 526
new slug gun
« Reply #22 on: August 27, 2004, 04:24:10 PM »
This is getting really old, but Ok, I'll address the ammunition points you made.  1. There's pretty much the same selection of 12 and 20 gauge slugs in my area.  I've never had a problem finding a variaty of 20 gauge sabots year round.  And I've bought a box or two of 20 gauge sabots mid season, not a problem finding them.  2. I, and most slug gun shooters, aren't reloaders of slugs.  We buy new ones.  Why?  Because most slug gunners, especially run of the mill pump 12 gauge sluggers, would rather watch the grass grow, or mow the grass for that matter, instead of sending 50 slugs downrange at the range.

What was all the 22lr and 9410 talk about?  Are you saying using a 20 gauge 260 grain 1900fps 45 caliber slug is like using a 40 grain HP 22lr on a deer???  Ha, that's funny!  :-D   I think a better comparison is a 45-70 shooting a 300 grain 1800fps 45 caliber slug.  Will that drop a whitetail?  I'm not looking at paper and saying "it has 1000ft/lbs of force, that's enough for a whitetail".  I'm saying a 45 caliber bullet, 1800-1900 fps, 260 to 300 grain, from a FIREARM (be it a rifle or saboted shotgun) has killed a whitetail like it was struck by lightning for well over 100 years.  Both with smokeless powder or black powder.  

You know, I'd dare say there isn't a big game specieis that walks North America that the 45-70 hasn't dropped.  Sure, most of the bigger bears and stuff were killed with larger bullets, but then if you buy the 20 gauge sabots (if you can't find them send 22khornet a PM, he's reloading 20 gauge sabots for his ultra 20, along with a few others here), and load up whatever 45 caliber bullet you want and really pump up the velocity.  There just isn't anything in North America that could walk away from a hot and heavy 45 caliber bullet.

This discussion is getting really old, you like your 12, fine, but don't put down people that prefer to shoot a lower recoil gun.  Do some reading on the 45 caliber bullets performance at different bullet weights and velocities.

You could look up 50 caliber muzzleloaders shooting saboted 45 caliber slugs and bullets.  Look up the how big the elk and bear and such that are taken with 50 caliber muzzy's shooting saboted 45 cal bullets and slugs.  

And then look up the 454 casull and it's capabilities and lower velocities comparied to the previous long guns I've mentioned.

Then look up what the manufactures use for their 20 gauge high performance slugs.  Like Federals "barnes Expander" which is a muzzle loader slug design.  Or winchesters partition golds which are it's 454 casull bullet.

The 20 gauge high performance slugs of today act more like a 45 cal centerfire rifle or muzzleloader than a shotgun.  If you don't want to accept it fine, you just don't know what you're missing.

Remember, we (all of us older sluggers) grew up shooting 12 gauge slugs, and alot of us still do from time to time.  So we know both sides of the fense.  From the sounds of it you've only been on the 12 gauge side of the fense.  Maybe it's time to come on over and see how green the grass is on the other side.  We all know how green the grass is on the 12 gauge side, and for the most part we like the 20 gauge side.  Like I said, you don't know what you're missing, so come on over!  

later,
scruffy
Hunting is 99% brain, 1% gun

Offline HuntenNut

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 270
new slug gun
« Reply #23 on: August 27, 2004, 07:03:46 PM »
Scruffy,

I am very familiar with muzzleloaders as the owner of an Encore and a Pedersoli double 12 shotgun, and former owner of several others.

I am also familiar with the 45-70.

The analogy does not hold, as the 45-70 uses a much more ballistically efficient bullet than the pistol bullets being used in those 20ga slugs you reference. They have the energy at the muzzle but peter out much quicker over the long haul.

This is also why the pistol bullet in the sabot idea is not the best load for the muzzleloader either. I don't believe all the hype thats published about "200 yard" shots with a 240gr 44 mag bullet from a muzzleloader. Many who make such claims are probably exagerating. This is from experience with my Encore and with other guns I have shot in the past. The best performers for long range shooting are good bullets designed for muzzleloading like Precision Rifle, again with high BC's.

Call me "old fashioned" for not having "crossed the fence", but I have 3 main objectives in choosing my weapon for hunting:

1) Accuracy
2) Highest level of performance I can afford and shoot accurately
3) Versatility and Availabilityof Ammo

My shooting comfort is factored into accuracy.

The 12ga is FAR superior ballistically, FAR more versatile for the reloader and for its uses, FAR more widely available, and only MARGINALLY intollerable for recoil in such a heavy gun. So I just can't see any reason to switch to the 20.

I am not putting anyone down for using it. Certainly if it works for you, then it works for you (thats a "tautology" for you logicians out there :P ). I am just saying that I prefer the advantages offered by the 12ga.

I am also listing and defending these as REAL advantages for the benefit of those who are trying to make a decision as to which gun to purchase for themself. I don't think it should presented that the 12ga is INTOLERABLE to shoot, cause it just isn't true with THIS gun. If someone is going to "your side of the fence" because they've been scared into believing the 12ga is going to knock them over, then they have been misinformed and may be "missing out" on "my side of the fence" which may be the "right side of the fence" for them, leaving them on the "wrong side of the fence".

Offline MSP Ret

  • GBO Supporter
  • Trade Count: (173)
  • Senior Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 8940
  • Gender: Male
new slug gun
« Reply #24 on: August 28, 2004, 02:18:53 AM »
:agree:, not sure if your right or wrong (I do tend to agree with you though) but that is the way to make an arguement and to make a point. Well done to everyone that posted on this topic, great arguements all.
Each "side of the fence" is left open for the user to decide, and those on each side can still have thier own opinions for thier own stated reasons....<><.... :grin:
"Giving up your gun to someone else on demand is called surrender. It means that you have given up your ability to protect yourself to a power that is greater than you." - David Yeagley

Offline wild willy

  • GBO Supporter
  • Trade Count: (2)
  • Avid Poster
  • *****
  • Posts: 228
new slug gun
« Reply #25 on: August 29, 2004, 07:13:58 AM »
ordered a 20 gauge yesterday I'll let you know how it shoots

Offline HuntenNut

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Contributor
  • ***
  • Posts: 270
new slug gun
« Reply #26 on: August 29, 2004, 11:32:21 AM »
Wild Willy,

Enjoy the gun. I am sure it will serve you well.

Offline hunter01

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Member
  • *
  • Posts: 17
Re: new slug gun
« Reply #27 on: January 07, 2005, 12:11:40 PM »
I ended up buying a 20 after owning my 12 for 4 years.  I can honestly say I've never missed a deer with my Ultra 12.  When I bought the 20 I figured I would get a flater shooter, lighter gun.  I was right, however even in a gun vice I get a little more shake with the 20 because of the weight.  As a result my 100 yard groups are around 3 inches on a calm day where the 12 will produce 1.5 - 2 inchers.  Federal vital shock 1900 fps are my number one choice.   I've tried them all!!!!Good Luck!
E-mail Ublyhunter@comcast.net

Offline joe527

  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Member
  • *
  • Posts: 8
20ga. Ultra Slugger with Nikon
« Reply #28 on: January 09, 2005, 12:18:52 PM »
I have the Ultra Slugger in 20ga. it is fine for deer out just as far as a 12ga. is. It will poke a half inch hole in him and he ain't going far sucking wind like that.
          I have the Nikon Pro Staff 2x7 shotgun scope and it is a very nice scope. Excellent optics, bright and clear edge to edge. Works well in dim conditions also.  Has adequate eye relief, 3+ inches.

Get what you feel fits you best, I chose the 20 because I knew it would do the job and the gun is slightly less in weight. Recoil had nothing to do with my choice, I am not recoil sensitive.
   
           The ammunition avalability is good for both the 20 and 12. True some places carry more 12 ga. stuff for now but as more states initiate a shotgun only season for deer more and more people are going to choose the 20 over the 12 and ammunition companies will continue to step up to the plate.  Almost every brand you can think of now offer atleast one type of 20ga. slug and most offer mutiple choices. All are high in cost, if you plan to do much shooting I hope you have deep pockets, or you can do what i have done and invest in some reloading equipment for shotshells and load your own. Actually you can be off and running for under 200.00 with a nice MEC single stage press and plenty of supplies to load a bunch of slugs.
                                                           HTH,
                                                                  Joe h.

Offline Busta

  • GBO Supporter
  • Trade Count: (5)
  • Senior Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2586
  • Gender: Male
new slug gun
« Reply #29 on: January 09, 2005, 01:42:20 PM »
Man, you can say that again! :wink:
U.S.A.F. Veteran
NRA Life Member