I had a Sportster 17HMR Bull, and didn't like it.....not the bull barrel or the caliber. I sold it and got Patty a Sportster 22 mag. The smallest three I have now are a 10/22, my Handis in 223 and .32-20.
Ever since that fateful day years ago when I was running a pair of my beagles, I have been a big bore nut. I was carrying a .54 T/C White Mountain Carbine with a PBR. I had a red squirrel about 30 feet up a white pine sittin' on a broken branch stub with his tail over his back chattering at me. I barked him through the bottom of the stub. Yeah, sure, barked him....he came down in two pieces which the dogs had before they hit the ground. I've always made it a practice to carry and hunt with all my guns large and small to stay tuned up with them.
I keep leaning toward the .44-40. Why? I guess it's like thejanitor said, another round with some history. And, as CW said, the .30-40 is in the same slot with at least three of my other rifles.....Of course the .44-40 is too with others....
Man....This ain't easy. Maybe I oughta go back to work to keep my mind occupied
Thanks to TopperT, I just finished putting together a nice 12 ga. Oh yeah, the barrel was lost in the mail for over two weeks. We'd both about given up on it. He was up chasin' yotes in the Allagash and thought I had it. He was shocked to find out it was missing.
You guys have come up with some good suggestions.......I wonder if I could get them all past Patty

I could probably do it if I fixed up a pretty one for her once in a while.
Pete