I much prefer the extractor, cause .45-70 cases are a pain in the butt to find in 24 inches of snow. All my Handis, thanks much to Tim, are extractors. If I need a second shot, the other hand isn't busy trying to catch a case, it has one ready to go. Pluck it out, stick it in. I can reload as fast or faster with the extractor, and here, we wear gloves most of the year. So farewell to those myths.
Tim, while we're on the subject, why doesn't H&R use your version of a better extractor? Tim has a design for an extractor that really gives you something to grab. It's just another of those "why don't they do it that way" things.
Pete