I don't think you made a mistke. I had a Savage lever action in .25-35 and it was a delightful rifle that was shockingly accurate. I sold it to a collector who wanted a .25-35 more than I did. At the time, I planned on buying a .250 Savage version to replace it and some 25 years later, I am still looking for the right rifle at the right price.
Many years ago, I hunted with a guy who used a Model 99 in .243 and even though one might argue that he SHOULD have limited his shots to 250 yards or less, he did no such thing. He had plenty of one-shot kills out 300 yards and beyond with the rifle. When I was a licensd guide, I had several clients who used M-99's in .300 Savage or .308 for the feral hog hunts I conducted along California's Central Coast region. They all did well with them.
I wish I had one!
JP