I have fire lapped two guns, both out-of-the-box Remington 700's. One was a 6mm VLS with a chrome-moly heavy barrel, and the other was a .300 WM with a stainless barrel of standard magnum contour. In both cases, the barrels cleaned a lot easier and did not foul as quickly after the fire-lapping. In both cases, accuracy was improved to the point where the .300 shot the best 3 shot group I have ever shot, period. It was 5/8" at 200 yards with a 168 grain A-Max. Both guns are now accurate and easy to clean. I will never put enough rounds through either to worry about the "accelerated throat wear", as nebulous as that may be. My sample is small and is not statistically significant, obviously, but I can only report what I know as fact.
That being said, I would never consider fire-lapping any of my Kriegers or the couple of Obermeyer barrels I have. I don't think all "factory" barrels would benefit from it, either. If you have a barrel that looks rough inside or takes forever to clean, this is a quick and relatively easy option to see if it helps. I wouldn't do it to improve accuracy, no matter what the claims from Tubb are. It did help in my case, but I have read other's anecdotal reports that claim just the opposite.
Fast Ed