I'm one of those guys who "grew out of" the .410. Started out shotgunning with a single shot break action in .410, with full choke. Got my first partridge on the wing with it, but shot it less and less as I grew into a teenager. Bought myself a new Remington 870 12 ga. pump on CHRISTmas and that was it.... Until an uncle, who was moving, happended to give me a lovely little Savage/Fox SXS .410 a couple of years ago.
I'm an avid rabbit/grouse hunter, but had been using 12 ga. for all upland game since I was 16. The 12 is a great gun. However, if you hit something with a 12, especially at close range, and you get a lot of spoiled meat. My brother and I trained ourselves to aim for the head, and we usually hit it, but there's always that one body shot... Anyway, after receiving the little double .410, I decided to take it along on my next bunny hunt. The beagles were on one inside of three minutes after slipping the leashes. Game on!!!
Now when I was hunting with the 12, you had a rather large "margin for error" when it came to bagging that bunny, since the odd alder branch or young spruce didn't really offer all that much impediment to that load of shot. With the .410, you sure aren't throwing as much shot, so you have to learn to be a little more selective in where and when you shoot and you have to learn when NOT to shoot. After a few hard looks from my beagles and a few digs from my brother about missing the "easy" shot on 'ol Bugs I set to work re-learing the art of the .410. I missed my first couple of opportunites and decided to pass on several more on that first hunt, but nevertheless, managed to bag several hares for the pot. It was a hunt that I'll always remember...
Its now a couple of hunting seasons later and I'm still using the .410. I believe it has made me a much better shot and a much better hunter. My success rate in the field is just as good, if not better, than when I was hunting exclusively with a 12 ga, and I haven't had to discard a single bunny or bird because of excessive pellet damage.
I now know why the .410 is called the "experts" gun. While I don't deem to call myself that, I sure like to think I'm on that road and will eventually arrive at that point.
Don't get me wrong though, I still hunt with the 12ga and there are obviously a number of hunting scenarios where it is much more logical than a small bore. Turkey and waterfowl hunting come immediately to mind. However, you shouldn't turn you nose up at the challenge a .410 can add to your next upland game hunt. Dust off those great old singles and doubles and take to the field. You won't be sorry!