Doc, from most reports, the 1:9" superlight .223 barrels don't like the bigger bullets, they seem to shoot the same lighter bullets in the 40-52g just as good as the 1:12" do, but they're also susceptible to barrel heat, so take your time in shooting those groups. It won't hurt to try some of the heavier bullets, each rifle is different and what works in one may or may not in another. A couple of bullets that shoot good in the 1:12" are the Win 64gr PP and the Sierra 63gr #1370, they have a good track record on deer if you read the reviews at Midway.
Tim