I say both.
Finish getting what you need in the encore.
Small game(22LR with open sights), Varmint (223 or 22-250 with 6-24X scope), Big game (308 or 30-06 with 3-9X40 scope), and 20ga. shotgun tube for the encore. That way you can go anywhre with one gun case and hunt everything there. After that I would get the H&R's to fill in the cool stuff inbetween and make dedicated pig, brush, pronghorn, bear, and what ever guns.