Very interesting posts. It kinda reminds me of the which is better... chevy vs ford vs dodge vs the imports. I personally drive a import truck. Why? The same reason I buy the firearms that I do. The freedom to choose. I own Rems, Rugers, savage, Tikka and beretta. I don't have a win. yet only because I may have liked the rifle etc but was the wrong caliber at the time. I have much more experience with CRF than push but I can't say anything negative about the push feed.
As far as to what is cheap or junk or of poor quality I feel is of that individuals personal experience or expectation of the firearm in question. I own some of the rifles that some here don't like. They shoot like a dream for me. Anything that man builds is not perfect. And some rifles like some ladies I know can be temperamental.
The issue that really gets under my skin and stopped me from buying what I thought was beautifully built Rem vl in a 223 was that J-Lock in the bolt. There was no way was I letting a lawyer somewhere dictate what should or shouldn't be on a rifle I was going to purchase. Because of that Rem lost a customer. And I don't need 8# trigger pulls either! No safety or heavy triggers beats proper training and common sense. Let the consumer with his dollar tell the tale.
urika20