If you don't plan on mounting a scope, then the 1895 wins by a fair margin. Of the two, the '95 has far better balance and handling, at least when compared to the older steel frame long action BLR (and I like BLR's, owning 3 short actions). My opinion is colored since I have not had the chance to handle the aluminum framed long BLR.
With a tang sight mounted on my Browning 1895, accuracy is all you could ask for in an iron sighted levergun. That said, my BLR's have no issues with accuracy either.