Just don't seem right to leave this one hangin' any longer, so here 'tis.
JEICMAWLAL = Jim wallace 
BNIALMLHTGIL  = Bill Tilghman
DEARLILMANSESDTUO = Dallas Stoudenmire 
EALCFAEBOG = Elfego Baca 
GTETOARLGFE = George Flatt 
IRKEETLTNA = Ike Lantier 
DRAEVHETAM = Dave Mather 
PTATTEGRAR = Pat Garrett