Really? I didnt know hornady brass wasnt reloadable. I have never tried it but thats a good nugget of info to hang onto. You dont think the hornady will penatrate an elk? I really dont know. The only other hornady bullets I use are SST's and they are a drastically different bullet. Locked and with a platic tip for initiation. They do fine on cow elk so long as they arent going like 3200 upon impact. I usualy step up to an interbond for such work. I actually dont even use them in my 7mm, for some reason the 139 grain flavor doesnt shoot worth a dern in that rifle, now the 154's are a different story, they shoot beautifully. I know it happens, but it still dont completly understand why. I have other 140 grainers that shoot great in that gun. I digress,,,,,,,,,,