I own both. For many years, I preferred the subtle, soft appearance of the Field Grade. All of mine were ordered with the optional laminated hardwood or micarta grips. However, when you tell me that you're rough on guns, and are going to scratch them anyway, I have to say that the Premier Grade finish is very easily restored to a pristine unblemished condition with the Scotchbrite Red, as stated by makilly. Accidents can happen in the field, and for the ease of restoring the gun's finish alone, I now prefer the Premier Grade.