I just ran into this thread and had to put my story in too. I have been using the past weekends to get ready for all the upcoming hunting. In particular, I wrung out my brother's and my Browning 71 carbines with a 265 grain bonded bullet I make.
First I re-read the two stories in Handloader, poured through Cartridges of the World and all my reloading manuals (Barnes was most helpful), used my Powley load calculator, and started a little lower with Steve Gash's recommended loads. Understand the heaviest bullets he tried were 250's, so I was careful w/my heavier 265s. I live in interior Alaska, so light bullets don't make much sense.
I then shot different powders (IMR4895, IMR4320, IMR4064, Reloder 19, WW760, IMR and H4350s, and Accurate 3100) for groups, extreme spreads and standard deviations. Once I found the three most promising, I started working them up til I found their limits in our carbines. My 71 seemed to be the more pressure sensitive, so all the loads were cut off to accomodate it.
In the end I settled on 56.0 grains of WW760 and CCI200 primers. All of the shooting was done with what started as new W-W Super brass. Out of my 20" carbine, I am averaging 2255 fps 12 feet from the muzzle, extreme spread of 32 fps, and a standard deviation of 14.1 fps; these are for 10-shot strings. During development I did all my shooting out behind the shop at 50 yards; after selecting the best load we went to a longer range. For 5-shot groups I was averaging 1 3/8" groups at 50 yards every time; at 100 yards they grew to 2 3/4", and a few went 3" as I got tired. Ken's carbine shoots about 18 fps slower with the same load and his groups are a smidgen smaller.
But the best part of all was when Ken nailed a 6 foot griz just a couple weeks ago. It was a broadside shot and broke both shoulders. The sow went down in the creek, then tried like hell to vacate the area! Ken put a finishing shot through her neck and the show was over. The first bullet was recovered on the far shoulder weighing 218 grains; the second bullet was lost, but left a 3" hole after blowing out the spine. We were both pretty happy with how well the bullets tore so deep and held up so well!
Runners-up for good loads were Accurate 3100 (I couldn't get enough powder into the case to keep going, but boy it was accurate every time) and H4350. The Hodgdon 4350 runs a little slower than IMR, but doesn't lose as much velocity when the weather starts getting cold. Also, the H4350 was almost as accurate as the 3100. My second best load is 54.0 grains of H4350 with CCI200s; they are running 2094 fps, but gave groups of 1 5/16" and 2"(?).
I developed all these loads in 60 - 75 degree weather and at 412 feet above sea level. I plan to check them again when we get down below zero for a comparison.
If you want to try them, please put the same effort I put into safety - back off, then work up. I only take responsibility for my face, not yours!
To sum up, I love the models 86 and 71! I hope this info inspires you to enjoy yours as much as I do.
Paul W. Tappen
Badger Bullets
2235 Blackstone Rd
North Pole, Alaska 99703
(888) 840-4937