I only have one barrel with a brake on it. Like Dinny, mine was a 14" barrel, that I added a non-removable 4" brake to to make it legal. Mine is a 44 Mag and has remained as such. It does not bark that badly, but louder than without, of course. If I stretched it out to a 445, I am sure it would bark much more. Mine is not for sale, I like it. The 44 Mag is not that intense, the higher the pressure and the more powder used (muzzle fireball), the louder it gets.
Most times, you can have a muzzle brake added that is removable. Some times they even come with thread protectors. For heavy kickers - when you are at the bench you shoot with the brake. When hunting, remove the brake and put on the thread cover. I found that when in a hunting situation, recoil is not nearly as noticeable as it is at the bench. Use the brake to develop loads, zero the scope or just plain fun shooting with out developing a flinch. Switch for your hunt and you will shoot with confidence. Of course you could use a weighted rest to do your bench shooting with and you would not need a brake. A good rest is not a whole lot more than the cost of 1 muzzle brake and from there, you can do each new gun for free.
For the most part (there are always exceptions) I think you will find that the people that do not like them, do not like them on other people's rifles. It is a free country so do as you wish.
Good Luck And Good Shooting