I got one here off the classified last fall (?), the thumbhole stock was already changed out and I didnt want it anyway, but the real part of the gun has been a dandy. Im a cast bullet guy and it has shot every load Ive tried in it to satisfaction, from 300, 340, 405 and 500's with light loads to class II 45-70 (Marlin type) loads. Just did a thorough cleaning after probably 100 lead rounds using a test bottle of the new S&W Bore Gel for a product review and it shows NO leading. BTW, that product works really well.
In short, mine is a shooter; based on it, get one!