I have a 3x Leupold on it, so it's not a sight issue. I'm thinking it could be the crescent butt plate, doesn't feel comfortable to me. Might be slipping without knowing it. I have Handi's in 30-30, .22 Hornet, and .223, and have no such problems with the other ones. That's the only other variable that I can think of between the guns. I've loaded .45 Colt for years, in other guns, with no accuracy issues. It makes sense that if there's inconsistences in fit, that could attribute to the stringing isuue. I'm going to remove the scope and try the irons(I shoot good with irons), that would eliminate scope or mount issues. I'm really leaning towards the butt plate, it's the only time I've used a cresent butt on a center fire. All my muzzleloaders have them, but their bigger and feel more comfortable.