Not to say your wrong or right but from the hunting stand point it is the differance when at dusk or dawn, I have seen many a hunt ruined when the guys optics gave out, you have to take into consideration you spend $600.00 on your gun $3000.00 for your hunt not to mention the expense for all your gear, time off work, time away from home, many nights spent dreaming about your hunt, then your scope goes!!!!!!!!!!!! all because you wanted to save a few bucks.
It is just like buying a quality gun, you buy it for the long haul, because you are only as good as your optics, I have mounted many high end scopes (leupold,zeis, burris,) on lever guns and pump shotguns, because these guys realized this.
So for just plinking, I can see your point, but for anything else it is really worth saving up for.
RON KONTOWSKY
ACTIONS BY R.A.K.