''college types who never stepped into the field''-precisely-and once I commented to a friend who was a professional forester that I came to the conclusion after walking up a valley on a spring bear hunt, and observing an grown back old cut,that they could have harvested the trees on the slopes, but left 50% of the trees in the gulleys to prevent washouts, he said-''we just paid for a huge study that basically was exactly what you said-but some of these guys have never set foot in the bush and used their eyes-all they do is work on ''models'' and in offices.
I think the same goes for game laws-the rational behind some of them is rediculous [ie allowing modern weapons but disallowing modern sighting systems that would help to ensure clean kills]